Rhiannon is named after a Fleetwood Mac song, and, as a rule, will not sleep with any man who asks ‘like the song?’ or ‘have you heard the song?’ or any other variation of song reference within the first ten minutes of learning her name. There has been one exception: a minor league baseball player she’d met when she was twenty. He had spiked blond hair caked in gel and blue eyes, a little stubble over a square jaw; he reminded her of someone back at college she’d just broken up with who she’d thought she was is love with.
She sits with her elbows perched on the table, peering across the room with narrowed eyes and pursed lips. She is aware that she could sleep with any man in the bar, but she thinks it’s because a man will sleep with anything pretty that shows them attention. She decides she will sleep with someone tonight.
Sitting to her left is Juliana, a college roommate and one-time best friend whom she hasn’t seen in almost a year. She’s just as beautiful as Rhiannon, if not more so, although she doesn’t know it. She certainly puts in the same effort – the gym and the salon and tanning and the vomiting in restaurant bathrooms and the hours analyzing bare thighs; the same effort went into the pink tank top and the jeans with the manufactured holes in the knees that flared out over her tennis shoes. Even more effort was put into the wavy, brown-rooted blonde hair that spilled beyond her pale shoulders. Her green eyes are raccooned with the same liner that Rhiannon is wearing. But she doesn’t know that she could sleep with any man in the bar, nor would she take comfort in that fact.
“How’s Ryan?” Rhiannon asks, examining her bare nails and cocking her eyes up at Juliana.
“Fine.” Juliana has been dating Ryan for the better part of two years. “I’m fucking someone else” she mumbles, her lips clamped to the cigarette she’s lighting.
“Who?”
“Dan.” Juliana has been sleeping with Dan, a friend from college, off and on, only when running into each other, never preplanned, for a little over a month now. Dan has been in love with Rhiannon for nearly four years. Since sophomore year of college, the two spent their afternoons together, amongst Juliana and others at first, but later in each other’s exclusive company. They spent many nights together, nights Dan thinks of as his happiest and Rhiannon thinks of as half-embarrassed anecdotes on the perils of dollar draft night. Since they stopped speaking nearly six months ago, everything that has happened to Dan has just been another thing without her in it.
“My Dan?”
“What do you mean ‘your Dan’?”
“Well, he was in love with me,” Rhiannon blurts out before she has time to think of her delivery. It comes out proud, territorial.
“Is,” Juliana whispers into her martini.
“How’d that start?” she asks, as if it’s some sort of laugh, some late night blind date show interview.
“Saw him around a lot. Talked to him a couple of times. Long talks.”
“That’ll do it.”
“I think I might be falling in love with him.”
“I wish I could.” Rhiannon’s bangs flutter upwards as she sighs.
Dan was en route to the very same bar they were at, a bar chosen by Rhiannon because of the unlikelihood of Dan’s presence there. She was right on in her assumption that it wasn’t a place you’d likely find him – with the steep prices and dim lighting and attractive people – but this is a world of chaos. Dan was being led there by Alanna, a girl he worked with five days a week for the past four months. She’d grown a sort of affection for him, laughing at his jokes and being heartbroken by all of the sad music he listened to while he read in the back of the kitchen. Most importantly, he intrigued her because he didn’t seem interested in her. Sure, they flirted, and she’d caught him eyeballing her breasts once or twice, but he talked to her, actually listened to what she had to say, rather than just reading from the lines of the script. She didn’t smoke, but she used to sit in the back alley with him while he did, on orange (his) and blue (hers) milk crates. Some days she would ask about what he was reading, which was usually one of Rhiannon’s favorite books. Other days she would moan about her hangover and tell him all about the previous night out. He would tell her to leave her boyfriend, like all the others did, but he didn’t say it so it would free her up.
That morning, like most, he had been slicing tomatoes while she sat next to him on the stainless steel countertop, dangling her legs over the edge, both of them silent and listening to the sad music. She asked what it was and he said Belle & Sebastian and she said it was different, and he agreed, and she said she liked it, and that made him smile, which he didn’t do often. She asked him what he had planned for the evening, and when he said something about staying in and reading, she demanded that he go out with her. She’d offered before, most Fridays or Saturdays, and he’d always politely turned her down, although she got the feeling that if she demanded he might comply.
And he did. He knew he was only going because she was pretty, and seemed interested in him, and he knew the only reason that interest existed was because he didn’t seem particularly concerned with fucking her, but he agreed to go anyway, because, like with Juliana, he thought having a pretty girl around might solve some problems.
“So how’s Chicago?” Juliana asks.
“Love it” Rhiannon says, rolling her tongue and taking a pull from her martini. “But I miss it here.” She wants to ask how Dan is doing, if he’s still drinking as much as she’d heard. She wants to compare notes on how he is in bed, ask if she knows what he’s planning to do with himself. She talks instead about the lawyer she’s being seeing, the one seven years her senior who glides them into clubs and can always score coke.
***
Ten minutes into the ride and Dan starts to think he should’ve stayed at home. Alanna drives a purple Japanese sports car. She’s listening to a hip-hop song about sex that sounds just like the last thirty he’d heard. He knew he should’ve stayed home. For some reason he’d convinced himself that tonight would be different, which he always managed to do when he went out. He was always wrong. Plus, he knew Rhiannon was back in town. He knew the odds of running into her were slim and none, but it’s always when faced with those odds that he usually ran into people, the people (nowadays, person) who could arrest him, narrow his entire focus, simply by walking into a room.
“You don’t like this song, do you?” She thinks he is deep and melancholy, too deep and melancholy to be affected by anything she could say or do; she doesn’t even consider that he himself is terrified, that the two-day shadow of hair on his face isn’t carelessness but a conscious decision, one painstakingly considered in front of the mirror, left on in an effort to appear rugged. He doesn’t care much about sleeping with her, but he’s still eager to impress her.
The first day she met him, right after he’d greeted her with a warm smile, she thought to herself ‘not a chance’. She wasn’t even really conscious of it then, it’s not something she does with every man she meets. And he’d done nothing but act polite when meeting her, but she thought it, and she’s remembering it for the first time, now, at a red light, and it’s curious to her, because now she’s thinking about sleeping with him, and she’s not sure that he’d go for it.
“No,” he says, almost apologetically. “I don’t.”
Alanna’s boyfriend is an outside linebacker for a Midwestern Division II school. He has eyes like diamonds and he believes he loves her as a person, but it’s something more akin to the coveting of her physical beauty, an entity or representation. If she weren’t attractive, he’d find her boring and naïve. Alanna’s never had a boyfriend who seemed genuinely interested in her outside of her beauty. She thinks that Dan is different. And while Dan does find her boring and naïve, there’s something else going on – a sort of ironic and comical mismatch, like an Eddie Murphy cop movie — that makes him happy. And, though he can’t exactly figure out why, he does really care about her.
Rhiannon is talking to a pair of men she’d found to buy her and Juliana a round when she sees Dan walking through the door with a girl. His brown hair is much shorter and choppier now. It matches his sweater, which appears to have been nice at one point, but is now woefully wrinkled and has a small hole near the armpit. He clearly hasn’t shaved in a couple days and his eyes look drained. He may have lost a few pounds. The girl is arrestingly beautiful, far more beautiful, in Rhiannon’s opinion (but not Dan’s), than Rhiannon. She isn’t sure whether to feel jealous or relieved.
Juliana is walking back from the bathroom when she sees them. She knows Alanna, from a Halloween party a few months ago. Her boyfriend was a friend of Ryan’s. He wore a pair of thick black glasses purchased from Walgreen’s and a purple sportcoat and walked around asking girls if they wanted to ‘shag’ (he didn’t even make an attempt at an accent). She didn’t really think about it at the time, but now she thinks how unimaginative it was; she wouldn’t have ever realized this if she had never met Dan.
“You don’t like this place, do you?” Alanna asks, crinkling her nose apologetically.
“No” he says, pursing his lips and glancing around as if he were visiting a foreign country. “I used to like places like this.” He almost adds ‘when I was happy’, but at the last second remembers who he’s with. Sometimes, in his head, these conversations happen and the people understand.
“Why’d you stop?” she asks, taking a pull from her martini but keeping her eyes fixed on his.
“Because the only people who go to these kinds of places are guys who want to meet or impress pretty girls.”
“And you don’t want to meet or impress pretty girls?” she asks coyly, flicking her head to the side and letting a smile crease her face.
“No.” Her head cocks upright and the smile flattens.
“Why not?”
“Because they’re generally really mean people,” he says flatly, just as he notices Rhiannon, who is talking to a car salesman with too much gel in his hair.
“Do you think I’m pretty?” Alanna knows Dan thinks she is pretty. Everybody thinks she is pretty. She has given up her integrity and sanity to ensure this.
“Of course.” He doesn’t say it consolingly or encouragingly like other guys she’s set this path of conversation up for. He says it matter-of-factly, as if in regard to a business proposal they’d both read over a hundred times.
“So you think I’m a mean person?”
“I don’t think you’re a mean person…but I’d be willing to bet you’ve been indoctrinated into a mean system.” Alanna doesn’t know what ‘indoctrinated’ means. She just nods her head. Dan lights a cigarette and steals glances at Rhiannon. He wants to leave.
“Do you want to leave?” she asks apologetically.
“No.”
***
“Dan’s here” Rhiannon deadpans, looking at herself in the bathroom mirror, where the two have sought refuge from the conversation of the car salesmen.
“I saw him” Juliana whispers.
“I kind of like the guy you were talking to…Eric.” she says cheerily, bouncing on her toes and bunching her shoulders.
“I don’t.” Juliana sits slumped in a small, faux-velvet chair, her arms making a V that slides between her knees.
“What’s wrong with you?”
“He’s in love with you…he’ll go to pieces when he sees you here.” She raises her eyes to meet Rhiannon’s, which are fixated on the mirror. “And you don’t care?”
“It’s not that I don’t care” Rhiannon says with a sigh used by housewives who describe their incorrigible children. “It’s that he goes to pieces…besides, he’s here with someone else.”
“But he’s in love with you.”
“And you’re in love with him.”
“Yeah, and as a result I want him to be happy…that’s how it works.” Rhiannon thinks this is the smartest thing Juliana has ever said; she realizes at once that she has never really loved anyone.
***
“Ok, you’re totally going to think I’m an idiot,” Alanna warns, rolling her eyes and swiping a strand of auburn hair behind her ear, “but what does ‘introctrinated’ mean?” Dan looks at her quizzically for a second before remembering their earlier conversation. Her earnest confusion melts his guts.
“It means I think you’re a sweet person…you’re just in a fucked up world.” Dan glances around, as if to imply that this bar were such a world.
“I think I’m going to break up with Matt.”
“I think that would be a good idea.” He smiles, and then reminds himself that she will only find another variation of Matt. “Do you want another drink?”
***
“So what do you do?” Eric asks like a game-show host.
“I’m in graduate school…in Chicago.”
“Wow. So you’re pretty smart, huh?” Rhiannon and Dan are both asked this question constantly. They never know how to respond. Neither knows that the other feels their pain in this respect.
“Yeah, I guess.”
“You got a boyfriend at graduate school in Chicago?”
“No…hey, I’ll be right back. I’m just going to grab another drink.”
“I can get it for you.”
“No. That’s fine…thanks.”
“Ok” he says throwing up his palms in display. Rhiannon rolls her eyes as she turns away.
***
“Hi.”
“Hey.” Dan looks at the floor. Rhiannon looks him in the eye.
“She’s cute.”
“She’s worthless.”
“How have you been?”
“Terrible. How’s the thirty-two year old?”
“Thirty-one.”
“Sorry…that’s not fair.” He looks her in the eye.
“No…it’s ok. I deserve that.” She looks at the floor.
Dan raises the two bottles in each hand. “I should get back.”
“Nice to see you.”
As he walks away she thinks to herself that if given the chance, both of them would choose the other’s exclusive company over the car salesman or the girl from work or anyone else in the bar. She realizes that even this realization – on both sides – cannot change a thing. When she feels the lump in her throat is liable to burst, she heads to the bathroom alone, sheds a few tears, touches up her make-up and prepares to go fuck the car salesman with too much gel in his hair.